Rare Jewish-Indian Haggadah found in Salford
A rare Jewish text, published for the “Black Jews of India” in the 19th Century, has been discovered in a garage sale in Salford. The 137-year-old Poona Haggadah, used by the Bene Israel community at Passover, was found by University of Manchester historian, Dr Yaakov Wise. He said he paid a “substantial” fee after recognising it at the sale.
“I knew it was a very rare book – in fact, it may be the only copy of it in Britain,” he said.The Prestwich-based historian said he was a regular at second-hand book sales as far away as Hay-on-Wye in Powys. He said he had come across the Haggadah, which features text in both Hebrew and Marathi, an Indian language, in a pile of books at a local sale in Salford’s Higher Broughton area. “A man had passed away and his family were selling his library,” he said. “There were hundreds and hundreds of books for sale, but as soon as I saw it, I knew what it was.” Dr Wise said he recognised it because he had given a lecture on the book’s original audience, the Bene Israel, in Liverpool a few years before.
The Bene Israel are known as “the Black Jews of India” because of their Indian appearance, as opposed to the “White Jews of India”, who he said were of Middle Eastern descent and had settled in the country much later. ‘Primary source’ The historian said he believed that the book had come to England during the post-colonial turmoil in India, when many Jews, who had British passports because of their work with the Imperial government, moved to the safety of London. He said the book then probably came to Salford “by sale or inheritance”.”The format and illustrations give an insight into the Black Jews,” he added.
“The illustrations, in particular, are fascinating, as the major Biblical figures, such as Moses and Abraham, look Western, while the people celebrating Passover are very Indian.” He said he had yet to check with the British Library in London and Oxford’s Bodleian Library as to whether the book was unique in Britain, but that it was certainly a very rare text. “There are very few books that have translations from Hebrew into any Indian language,” he said. “As far as I know, there is only one of these in the whole of North America and that is in the Library of Congress in Washington DC.”
Originally published here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-13907225
Editors Note: This email was received September 1, 2011:
I was surprised to read the article about the purchase of a “rare” Haggadah of the Bene Israel Community in India. It is rare but has been known to research scholars for years. It was not supported or funded by David Sassoon. Additionally, David Sassoon never had the title of Sheikh. However more disturbing is the statement that the Bene Israel were known as “The Black Jews of India”. I am a Bene Israel, ordained in New York as a Rabbi, and take exception with this statement as the Bene Israel are not Black Jews. Further, Indian Jews did not leave India because they felt they would be safer in London. Indian Jews were never discriminated against nor oppressed at any time as has happened in Europe. Indian Jews are proud citizens of India and did not leave because of issues of safety. If you need more information on “The Jews of India” please go to our web site: Jewsofindia.org
Rabbi Romiel Daniel
President, Indian Jewish Congregation of USA
President, Rego Park Jewish Center, New York